*Amended Copy
April 7th 2011
Community Board 2 Monthly Meeting and Public Hearing
Attendance
Andrew Anzalone Diane Ballek
Kate Brennan
Bernard Callegari Jean Carubia
Bessie Cassaro Barbara Coleman
Joseph Conley Stephen Cooper
Emilia Crotty David DeCicco
Lisa Deller Don Dodelson
Kenneth Greenberg Richard Gundlach
Anne Hart Rev. Joseph Jerome
Tom Kalamaras Marie Konecko
Sheila Lewandowski Dominic Lippolis
Guadalupe Marzana Gregory Matos
Donald McCallian Gertrude McDonald
Dorothy Morehead Patrick Murray
Patrick O’Brien Evan O’Neil
Moitri Chowdhury Savard
David Shin Lauren Springer
Carol Terrano Karolina Tosi
Nick Troya Al Volpe
Robert Wilkanowski * Mary English
Absentees
Terri Adams Sandra Bigitschke
Thomas Casey Brian Flynn
Mohammed Choudhury Jewel Luis Jimenez
Ellen Kang Rita Manton
Taina Hernandez McShane
Norberto Saldana
Community Board 2 Staff
Debra Markell Kleinert, DM Mary Ann Gurrado
Guests
Assemblyman Michael Den Dekker
Ed Babor, Congresswoman Maloney’s Office
Matthew Lerch, Senator Gianaris’s Office
Michael Mallon, Councilman Dromm’s Office
Joe Kenton, Councilman Van Bramer’s Office
Sam Goldman,
Thomas Cacan, Gazette
Alan Krawitz,
Jason Banrey,
Luke Adams Minjn Jung
Andrew Barnes George Stamatiades
Shiyuan Chen Linda Diep
M. Dan Bach Arthur Wiener
Beau Gallo James Bray
Robert Flahive William Garrett
Manuel del Nido Hilary Kersten
Rose Tibaldi Mary Tibaldi
Dee Jay Bankhead Jen Milburn
Mike Son K&D Mesquita
Matt Symons Boris Pincus
Troy Bonson Katherine Keeble
Patricia Dorfman Dorothy Kominsky
Gerald Walsh Wendy Chan
Chris White Veronica Seiferth
Michael Chen Glenn Seiferth
Marcie Kesner Mary Taub
Tom Smith Penny Lee
Agenda
Pledge of Allegiance
Comments by Public Officials/Guest Speakers
Assemblyman Den Dekker
The Assemblyman spoke about the portion of the Community Board 2 District that he represents, which is the Woodside area; Assemblywoman Cathy Nolan represents most of the Community Board 2. Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about how fortunate the community is to have Assemblywoman Nolan as their representative.
Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about the recent Budget submitted by Governor Cuomo. He said that Assemblywoman Nolan worked extremely hard to win back funding that was initially cut from the community’s Budget. Assemblyman Den Dekker explained that this Budget is not in the community’s favor however, it was accepted in order to avert an “extender”, where by the restorations the elected officials were working on would have been lost. The Education portion of the Budget was successful due to the extreme efforts of Assemblywoman Cathy Nolan.
Assemblyman Den Dekker commended Councilperson Van Bramer and his commitment to the community. Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about Article 20 funding, which is allocated for the operation of our Senior Centers. This funding has been restored in the Budget however the Mayor would be responsible for where and how the funding is spent. The City Council must be extremely diligent with regard to how the Mayor spending funding from Article 20.
There was many other aspect of the Budget that Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about:
· Cap on Malpractice for Pain and Suffering. Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about the impact of this provision on children or retired constituents. The funding budgeted for someone’s death or incapacitation due to the negligence of doctors and/or hospitals was budgeted at $250,000. This was submitted while offering the message that a person not working is only worth that amount of an award. Assemblyman Den Dekker disagreed with this conclusion. He said this is not a Budget item but a moral issue. Assemblyman Den Dekker expressed concern for setting a precedent for Pain and Suffering Law Suits moving forward. This item was incorporated into the Budget because there were cuts planned to be made to hospitals and in return the cut would allow for the reduction of medical malpractice insurance premiums, which would then be consistent to the Cut given to hospitals.
· He said that the Budget was submitted early due to the lack of negotiating forums and that he and Assemblywoman Nolan fought very hard to restore some of the cuts.
· Assemblyman Den Dekker expressed great concern about the recent coordinated campaign to pass devastating budget cuts and their impact on college students who struggle with tuition costs, the impact on Early Childhood Intervention Programs, Youth Employment Programs, etc.
· Assemblyman Den Dekker spoke about next year’s projected Budget. Should the projections discussed remain and the cuts proposed remain while the economy improves, next year’s deficit would decrease to $2 billion dollars. It is possible that the City could have a balanced Budget. Typically, the State is one year behind the economy. The Assemblyman spoke about surplus and restorations to recently cut programs.
Assemblyman Den Dekker entertained questions.
Presentation by Claudia Filomena, Mayors Office of Community Affairs
Ms. Filomena spoke about how the Community Affairs office is the eyes and ears of the community while working with local elected Officials. Ms. Filomena spoke about Emergency Response Work and Family Assistance Centers, which address quality of life Issues such as a Graffiti removal program, which is a free service. Ms. Filomena spoke about Community Clean-up Program that provides materials.
Ms. Filomena spoke about working with the MTA to clean up the graffiti on the No. 7 line, which has been difficult. The Community Affairs office also works closely with the Department of Transportation, the Department of Buildings, etc. The Community Affairs office also focuses to bring City Agencies together as well as assist with the expedition of resolving issues.
Ms. Filomena distributed business cards and entertained questions from Attendees.
Public Hearing
Consumer Affairs Application
In the Matter of an Application for a Consumer Affairs Renewable Revocable Consent License for an Unclosed Sidewalk Café with 10 Tables and 20 Seats; Mickey’s Place on 43 rd Street; LTD a/k/a Bar 43
There were no comments offered in favor or in opposition for this Application. Mr. Conley closed this item.
And
FDNY Fire Department Technical Services Warehouse,
The Proposed Action is the Acquisition of a Portion of a Privately owned Technical Service Warehouse, 34-24 Hunters Point Avenue, Long Island City, in the Sunnyside Section of Queens in the Community Board 2 District. The Parcel is Currently being used by the FDNY for Equipment Storage (Firefighter Tools, Ladders, Fire Hoses and Emergency Cache by the Bureau of Fleet Services. This Equipment used During the First 24 Hours of a “
An FDNY representative was in Attendance to entertain questions regarding this Application.
Ms. Deller asked for a detailed description for the function of the warehouse.
The representative explained that this warehouse is utilized by the FDNY for storage of equipment needed in case of an emergency. The warehouse is visited twice per week; Monday through Friday for inventory purposes and restocking is done, as needed. Questions were entertained.
And
FDNY Fire Department Back-up Radio Transmitter, 32-02 Queens Boulevard, Long Island City; (ULURP (CEQR: 11FDO002Q)
The Proposed Action is the Acquisition of a Portion of the Roof of a Privately
An FDNY representative was in Attendance to entertain questions regarding this Application.
And
Discussion on the
Mr. Conley explained that this parking garage was never fully utilized during its 30 year tenure. It has been argued that the parking garage was developed in the wrong area and was difficult for motorist to reach the building through Bridge traffic. During the garage’s peak operations, there were many manufacturing jobs in the area. Mr. Conley also explained that the number of vehicles that were parked in the garage were vehicles parked by the Department of Transportation which monopolized parking spaces in that garage. This was subject to criticism. The School Safety Department also utilized the parking lot, as well.
Mr. Conley explained that the community would like to have available parking spaces but located further east.
Mr. Conley stated that EDC and DCAS were in attendance to offer a summary of this item.
Ms. Marilyn Lee of EDC was in attendance to discuss this Application. She stated that a team of experts was also in attendance to entertain questions regarding this Application.
In 2001
Mr. Conley stated that once the Meeting reaches the Land Use portion of this Agenda, a presentation would be offered.
Gerry Walsh, Dutch Kills Civic Association
Mr. Walsh testified in regard to the Gotham Center Garage. He said that he has been a Dutch Kills resident for 35 years and spoke about how the garage was un-utilized and developed incorrectly. Mr. Walsh spoke about the lack of retail stores in the building. Mr. Walsh stated that there are no longer manufacturers in the area and zoning has been modified. Mr. Walsh spoke about 12 additional hotels that have been developed with very little or no parking. Guests continue to search the area for a parking spot.
Mr. Walsh stated that the community should not make a mistake and express concern for the future of the area. Mr. Walsh stated that retail stores are needed in the area and retail stores require parking.
Mr. Walsh spoke about the hotels that do not provide parking and stated that this is a tremendous decision and the neighborhood is vastly becoming residential and needs additional parking.
Mr. Walsh spoke about the parking terms in the garage for residents and about how the Department of Transportation occupied two prime levels (1 st and 2 nd floor) without limits. Residents that were forced to park five flights up and there were residents that were attacked in the garage. Mr. Walsh continued to speak about the change in the area and how the area is developing into a residential community.
Mr. Conley referred to Mr. Walsh’s comments regarding hotels. The Dutch Kills Civic Association is not within the Community Board 2 District. Mr. Conley explained that residential parking developed for Queens West has been underutilized as well.
Mr. Conley addressed the retail store comment and said there were no plan for the area.
Mr. Conley stated that the development of hotels should provide ample parking for guests.
Mr. Conley spoke about the parking lot behind the Chase Bank. The lot has been closed and this parking lot has been discussed for parking in the area.
Mr. Walsh expressed how City vehicles monopolize parking throughout the area, including local schoolyards.
Mr. Walsh entertained questions.
Mr. Conley stated that the Community Board offices would seek to create a turnover of City vehicle parking. Mr. Conley stated that he would work with Mr. Walsh with regard to this issue.
Mr. Walsh suggested that the garage offer monthly parking for residents of the area.
George Stamatiades, Dutch Kills Civic Association
Mr. Stamatiades expressed concerns for residents located north and south of
Mr. Stamatiades explained to the Attendees that the City of
Mr. Stamatiades spoke about the difficulties the residents endure daily with regard to parking. Residents cannot complete typical daily errand and tasks and return home to find a parking space without continuous searching for a new parking space. Mr. Stamatiades stated that the experts do not live in the area and the community is left with their mess. Mr. Stamatiades spoke about the commitment offered to the community with regard to traffic congestion once the Home Depot was developed. The community was assured the community that this development would only attract 7 cars per hour. Mr. Stamatiades expressed the concern for the promises offered to the community that are not kept.
Mr. Stamatiades urged the Community Board to oppose this Application. Mr. Stamatiades explained that parking for the community is crucial.
Renewal of Special Permits; Silvercup West Renewals; Technical Memorandum
Discussion on the Silvercup West Renewals (060325 ZSQ, 060326 ZSQ, 060327 ZSQ, 060328 ZSQ). Application for Renewal Pursuant to Section of the Zoning Resolution of three Special Permits and one Authorization Related to the Silvercup West Project. This Discussion is only on the Technical Memorandum with Ms. Marcie Kesner and Mr. Marty Taub.
Ms. Kesner was in attendance to discuss the Silvercup West proposal that was approved by the Community Board, the Department of City Planning and the City Council Commission in 2006.
Ms. Kesner spoke about the request for the Renewal of the Special Permits and Authorization that was granted in 2006. She explained that this project calls for the construction of 8 studios, approximately 1,000 residences and approximately 600,000 square feet of office space, community facility space, catering hall and over 1 acre of publicly accessible open space that includes a 500-foot long esplanade along the East River.
The Rezoning, Text Amendment and Certification that were granted in order to enable the development of this Project in 2006 have not lapsed. The Special Permits that were granted for the Project do lapse after 4 years but can be renewed for a 3-year period.
The Special Permits allow for the construction for a 1,400 space accessory parking garage. There is also a Special Permit that would allow for a new Silvercup sign that would face the waterfront. It would be designed to mimic the current Silvercup sign above the existing main lot. Ms. Kesner spoke about authorizations regarding the design waiver of the waterfront zoning for the open space.
Ms. Kesner stated that the in order to support this Application, the City Planning Commission must find that the authorization granted four years ago are valid to date.
The design and shape of the site, the shape of the buildings and the landscaping remain as in 2006.
The parking garage would require the needs of the employees, visitors and residents of the development. In order to update the analysis, Mr. Marty Taub, the Traffic Engineer studied the Project in 2006. Mr. Taub conducted an updated analysis last summer.
There were no Attendees at this Meeting that spoke in favor or opposition regarding this Application.
To Receive Public Comment
City Planning Application; Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning
Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning (110207 ZRQ, 110208 ZRQ, 110209 ZRQ) City Planning has undertaken the Rezoning of the Sunnyside/Woodside Area. The Study Area Consists of Approximately 130 Blocks, and 2,800 Lots. It is Generally Bounded by 39 th Street to the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway from West to East and from Broadway to the Long Island Expressway; Brooklyn-Queens Expressway from North to South.
Mr. Conley explained that there have been a number of Public Hearings as well as a number of presentations offered regarding this item. Public Comment would be accepted for this item.
There were no Attendees at this Meeting that spoke in favor or opposition regarding this Application.
Board Meeting
Attendance
Present-40; Absent-10
A Quorum was Present at this Meeting
Approval of Minutes
A Motion was made to approve the March 2011 Community Board 2 Monthly Meeting and Public Hearing Minutes. The Motion was seconded. The Motion was unanimously approved.
Public Comment
Mr. Conley explained the criteria with regard to Public Comment speaking. Mr. Conley stated that respect to the Speaker’s presentation is required. Whether a presentation is favored or opposed by an Attendee(s), those comments must remain until the Speaker’s 3 minutes has lapsed. Once the Speaker’s comments have been completed, a Q&A would be conducted.
Matt Symons, Parks and Recreation
Mr. Symons was in attendance to discuss Parks developments.
Anti-Litter Initiative: The information for involvement is offered on the Parks and Recreation website. Mr. Symons explained that while the City’s Budget continues to reduce, the Parks Department is seeking involvement from communities to assist with the maintenance of the City’s parks.
Smoking Ban in New York City Parks: This law would be in effect as of May 23 rd 2011. All New York City Parks, with the exception of median strips, boardwalks, sport stadium rounds, public golf courses, would have this law enforced.
Mr. Symons stated that smoking is prohibited in playgrounds, pools and inside stadiums as well as Plazas such as
Mr. Symons entertained questions from Attendees.
Boris Pincus, the Board of Elections
Mr. Pincus was in attendance to discuss the recruitment for poll employees for the Board of Elections. Flyers and Applications were made available at this Meeting. Mr. Pincus entertained questions from Attendees.
Troy Benson
Mr. Benson was in attendance to discuss P.S. 78 in
Mr. Benson said he has been meeting with P.S. 78 and asked if there were any representatives from the Department of Education at this Meeting. There were none however, Mr. Conley announced Mr. Joe Kenton from Councilperson Van Bramer’s office was in attendance.
Mr. Benton asked whether Mr. Kenton could expand the Pre-K Program and the Kindergarten at P.S. 78.
Mr. Conley explained to Attendees that the current debate regarding the new proposed school and the fate of P.S. 78. Discussions with DOE are to preserve P.S. 78 for Pre-K and Kindergarten students. To date, the decision by the DOE has not been announced.
Mr. Kenton offered an update to this issue from a meeting hosted last fall.
Mr. Benson spoke about information received regarding the school. This is an issue that the school would focus on in July. A plan must be implemented before September 2011. Mr. Benson spoke about many families in
Mr. Conley explained that P.S. 78 has been overcrowded for years but that school must remain. The Community Board is waiting for the DOE to Program the space. The Community Board would follow-up on this issue.
Ms. Terrano stated that a petition should be submitted to the Department of Education. Mr. Conley explained that there was a well-attended meeting in October regarding this issue and that there are new young families in the neighborhood that need the school. Ms. Terrano expressed concern for infrastructure.
Mr. Benson entertained questions from Attendees.
Katherine Keeb
Ms. Keeble is a resident of
Ms. Keeble stated that although she is happy living where she is now, she is considering moving because of the school situation. Ms. Keeble stated that she was also told that registering her son for the 1st grade would not be a guaranteed seat.
Ms. Keeble is in attendance seeking guidance and assistance regarding this matter.
Mr. Conley told Ms. Keeble to continue to stay in contact with Mr. Kenton of Councilperson Van Bramer’s office.
Patricia Dorfman
Ms. Dorfman is a resident of Sunnyside and Creative Director of the Sunnyside Post, VP of the Sunnyside Chamber of Commerce and VP of the 108 Police Community Council.
Ms. Dorfman read a statement to Attendees, which addressed Mayor Bloomberg to not sign the Bill renaming the
Ms. Dorfman asked Attendees if there was anyone who believed that the “people’s” Bridge, the Ed Koch Queensboro Bridge, was renamed on behalf of the people. Ms. Dorman asked Attendees if anyone believed that renaming a Bridge have anything to do with honoring a former Mayor. Ms. Dorfman stated that this was a Mayor offering a “present” to another Mayor in a way that he would want to be honored.
Ms. Dorfman asked why Council members
Ms. Dorfman stated that Mayor Bloomberg should give the Council people who voted for this Bill a chance to restore the damage done to their re-election chances.
Ms. Dorfman asked attendees to sign a petition to request that Mayor Bloomberg not sign this Bill.
Luke Adams
Mr. Adams was in attendance to oppose the renaming of the
Mr. Adams suggested naming a subway tunnel after Ed Koch.
Dorothy Kominsky
Ms. Kominsky spoke about Woodside. Ms. Kominsky spoke about the lack of improvement in the community. Ms. Kominsky compared the community in 1968 to date.
Issues along
Ms. Kominsky testified about:
· the trash, debris and dirt in the crosswalks along
· The dangers of crossing
· How the
· about homeless people living in the unoccupied building on
Wendy Chan
Ms. Chan is a resident of
Ms. Chan spoke about the increasing population in the
Ms. Chan commented on the elimination of Alternate Side Parking, which has resulted in long-term parking within the neighborhood. The streets have become littered, she said, and adding proposed parking in the median would be dangerous. There are young families in the area. A portion of the area has a basketball court. Ms. Chan expressed concern for children chasing loose basketballs near moving vehicles. That area should not have increased vehicle traffic.
Ms. Chan spoke about the vibrant community and commended those in attendance and active to improve the quality of life in the area.
Michael Chen
Mr. Chen was in attendance to speak about Woodside. He spoke on behalf of residents of 63 rd Street about the proposed development of a five-story building, (7 units), that would include a penthouse and medical offices at 37-40 63 rd Street without providing any parking.
Mr. Chen spoke about the Zoning requirements with regard to this type of development. The Zoning for this type of development requires one parking space per unit or minimum of 70% of all units. He stated that this development is located on a small lot and that the Department of Buildings issued a Waiver to the developer for the parking requirements due to the size of the lot.
Mr. Chen stated that Zoning Laws must be enforced and stated that the DOB must notify the developer stating that a smaller structure must be developed and parking must be included within this development.
63 rd Street from
Mr. Chen stated that this block has mostly one-family homes with driveways that currently hinder street parking. Mr. Chen explained that adding this proposed building would hinder parking even further. Mr. Chen expressed concern for double-parking and blocked driveways and stated that the residents consider the proposed building as a fire hazard and lack of green space.
Mr. Conley asked Mr. Tom Smith of the Department of City Planning if there were any developments on this issue that could be offered to the Attendees. This issue is related to the currently Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning Project.
Mr. Smith addressed this item for Attendees.
Under the existing Zoning in the area, which would be voted on at this Meeting, the developer would be allowed to develop the proposed building and not required to provide parking. Mr. Smith stated that this issue is one of the reasons why the Department of City Planning amended the Rezoning in Sunnyside/Woodside.
Mr. Smith explained that the demolition has already begun.
Mr. Conley inquired about Appeals. To date, Mr. Smith stated that he has not received any information regarding the Appeal. Should the foundation not be in place before the Zoning has been activated by this summer, the developer would not be authorized to move forward with construction.
Mr. Smith entertained questions from Board Members.
Chairperson’s Report
New Community Board 2 Member
Mr. Conley introduced and welcomed Community Board 2’s newest Board Member, Mr. Nick Troya. Mr. Troya is a resident of Woodside. Welcome, Nick!
Walking Tour in
Mr. Conley and Commission McCarthy of the Department of Transportation conducted a Walking Tour on
Visioning for Sunnyside/Woodside
Mr. Conley met with Commissioner McCarthy of the Department of Transportation regarding the modification of parking meter timing on
Speaker Quinn’s Pledge
Mr. Conley reminded the Attendees that Speaker Quinn assured the community that the bus stop at
Mr. Conley congratulated Ms. McDonald for her hard work and well-deserved victory.
Stop Light Addition
Mr. Conley commended Community Board 2 Member, Andrew Anzalone for his diligent efforts for the addition of a stoplight on
Mr. Conley reminded Attendees that the Community Board continues to work and fight for the community.
Hunters Point South
Construction has begun. The dog run on 2 nd Street would remain open temporarily until construction nears that location.
Parks Department Meeting Regarding Construction on the
Mr. Conley spoke about the construction on the
Green Facility
Mr. Conley spoke about the recommendation of moving that facility under the
This location has been closed. Mr. Conley explained that while the concept was a good one, the execution and operations were poor.
Press Conference at the Asphalt Facility at
Mr. Conley stated that it was well attended. The message sent was that
St. Raphael’s Food Pantry
Sunnyside Community Services is working to improve the Program, the data, how it is collected, etc.
Signs for Television or Movie Production
Cones cannot be placed until the date and time of production that is listed on the Permits. The Mayor’s office was contacted.
Traffic Accident(s) at
Mr. Conley spoke about the second accident at this location. The first accident was fatal. Both accidents occurred at the same location.
Community Board 2 has requested that the Department of Transportation re-visit this location to determine why these accidents occurred at the same location and develop a plan to prevent any more accidents.
Mr. Volpe spoke about the elimination of a lane. Mr. Conley spoke about speeding at that location.
Presentation by DOT Commissioner McCarthy Regarding the Maspeth Truck Bypass
The Proposal offered is for the modification of the routes on
Modifications from
23 rd Street and
Mr. Conley spoke about recently learning of the vast amount of traffic accidents at this location.
This is a Proposal. The center median on
Vote by Community Board 2 in Opposing of the Renaming of the
A Motion was made that Community Board 2 resolves that the Board is against the renaming of the
The vote was unanimous by a show of hands.
Chairperson present but not voting
District Manager’s Report
There were no Reports offered at this Meeting.
City Planning Report
FDNY Applications
The Applications were brought before the Community Board since each of the facilities had been operating under a Licensed Agreement. The Applications have come before the Board to officially request a Lease.
Committee Reports
Land Use Committee
Vote on Consumer Affairs Application; Renewable Consent License for an Unenclosed Sidewalk Café with 10 Tables and 20 Seats; Mickey’s Place on 43 rd Street, Sunnyside; LTD a/k/a Bar 43
Presentations were offered to the Land Use Committee. This location is in good standings with the NYPD; no complaints have been filed. The Land Use Committee voted In Favor of this Application.
A Motion was made to approve this Renewal Application. The Motion was seconded.
35 In Favor 1 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on FDNY Technical Services Warehouse,
Vote on FDNY Back-up Radio Transmitter,
Ms. Deller outlined the Applications from the FDNY. The FDNY went before the Land Use Committee regarding these Applications.
Vote on FDNY Technical Services Warehouse,
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on FDNY Back-up Radio Transmitter,
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning, (110207 ZRQ, 110208 ZRQ, 110209 ZRQ)
Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning (110207 ZRQ, 110208 ZRQ, 110209 ZRQ) City Planning has undertaken the Rezoning of the Sunnyside/Woodside Area. The Study Area Consists of Approximately 130 Blocks, and 2,800 Lots. It is Generally Bounded by 39 th Street to the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway from West to East and from Broadway to the Long Island Expressway; Brooklyn-Queens Expressway from North to South.
Ms. Deller commended the hard work and one year dedicated by Mr. Tom Smith of the Department of City Planning regarding this Rezoning Project. Mr. Smith attended several community meetings. Mr. Smith also continuously came before Community Board 2 Committee’s and the Full Board with updated data for this Project. The Land Use Committee unanimously voted In Favor of approving the final Zoning Application.
The goal of this Application is to protect the character of the neighborhoods as well as provide new opportunities for the community, provide Zoning incentives for affordable housing along
Ms. Deller said that the Community Board would continue to work with Mr. Tom Ryan of Woodside to address the zoning needs of his community, which was not part of this application.
A Motion was made to approve the Zoning Application. The Motion was seconded.
35 In Favor 1 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on Gotham Center (110225 PPQ); 28-10 Queens Plaza South, Jackson Avenue, 42 nd Road and 28 th Street, Long Island City
Mr. Conley clarified a recent question regarding instances where he has recused his himself with regard to discussions regarding
Ms. Deller offered a summary of this item. The Proposal is to reduce the number of parking spaces required at this site from 1,150 to 550 spaces. Ms. Deller stated that the rationale for this modification is that the previous parking lot was underutilized and there is a desire to pursued commuters to travel via public transportation versus parking in the lot and traveling into
Ms. Deller spoke about the difficult decision regarding a conclusion voting in favor of this Application but ultimately did vote unanimously In Favor with stipulations stating the need for a study in the area for new potential parking in the area.
Mr. Cooper offered a summary of initial discussions regarding this location and parking spaces. Mr. Cooper expressed concerns that should the Community Board agree to release the 600 spaces, would the developer provide those 600 spaces elsewhere as promised within this Proposal for the Application modification?
Mr. Andrew Barn of the New York Economic Development Corporation spoke about the above-mentioned question. Mr. Barn believed that it would not be an easy task to persuade or convince the developer to create parking in another area of the community that is not associated with the facility being constructed for the NYDC.
Mr. Barn spoke about the City returning to the “parking lot business” and believed to be in contrary with the DOT.
Mr. Barn spoke about the discussions in favor and opposition of this Application.
Mr. Cooper inquired about the status of the facility. A representative from Tishman Speyer spoke about the strategy for the site.
Mr. Cooper spoke about how the developer entered into a Contract with New York City with conditions that there would be a specific amount of square footage develop along with 1,150 parking spaces but is now requesting to be allowed to renege on the portion of the Agreement which would eliminate more than half of the parking spaces promised or required within the Contract.
Mr. Cooper spoke about the development of hotels in the area that do not provide parking and asked if the spaces are not provided now, when those spaces will be developed.
There was discussion about the Environmental Assessment Statement that was prepared for this Application took into consideration development on the site as well as development, both office and residential within the surrounding area. The 550 spaces are not just to satisfy the actual site, but also to satisfy the neighborhood.
The longer-term planning aspect under discussion with regard to where additional parking could be provided, should the additional parking is not provided on this site, all the Environmental Impact Statements have been identified as the “most horrific site for public parking” and the Land Use Committee has recognized this finding. It also recommended additional sites such as the former parking lot on the MTA site. This site is across the Plaza.
The zoning provides for an additional 250 public parking spaces on that MTA site. The Department of City Planning is currently in the process of discussions with the MTA regarding the redevelopment plans for that site. This is a valuable site. The site has a lot of development potential. The MTA must work with the community and the DCP when they are ready to develop on that site.
The Department of City Planning would continue to seek additional appropriate parking spaces as the area continues to develop.
This neighborhood is developing and can no longer provide commuter parking; parking for residents, businesses, etc. are needed as the area continues to grow.
Questions were entertained.
Representative for Tishman Speyer, Mr. Bob Flahive of Kramer Levin spoke about the new facility. Mr. Flahive stated that building was intended to house the New York City Department of Health. There are 162 spaces limited to accessory use; an employee or visitor would be offered access to those spaces. Tishman Speyer’s intention is to operate that garage as an Accessory Garage. At this time, Tishman Speyer is seeking to convert the 162 accessory spaces into public spaces.
Mr. Flahive entertained questions.
Mr. Conley spoke about the improvement of air quality, additional people in the area that do not live to the community, would it serve the community in a way that the community hopefully anticipates, where is the location that would be appropriate and comparative to the development under discussion, etc.
Mr. Flahive continued to entertain questions.
There was discussion of two other parking facilities in the area. The Court Square Municipal Garage on
There was discussion about the utilization of the building. This would be local retail not destination retail. There was discussion of City employees, as well.
There was discussion about how the number of parking spaces at 1,150 was arrived at. There was discussion regarding the development of the area versus the rundown area when the garage was operating but not fully utilized. The studies were not conducted when the amount of parking spaces, at 1,150, were offered.
Mr. Flahive continued to entertain questions.
Ms. Deller confirmed that the parking spaces are being sought for the neighborhood but not necessarily at this facility.
Ms. Deller stated that the Application could be opposed with a friendly amendment. The stipulation would outline provisions that
There was discussion about how the facility has been closed for three years and those vehicles have either been absorbed in other options of the parking network or have seized driving into the area all together.
Mr. Cooper spoke about the Community Board’s two options; either completely oppose the Application or approve with stipulations for the commitment of additional parking within a reasonable time-frame.
A Motion was made to oppose the Application for Tishman Speyer to reduce the amount of parking from 1,150 spaces to 550 spaces. The Motion was seconded.
24 In Favor 12 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on Silvercup West Renewals (060325 ZSQ, 060326 ZSQ, 060327 ZSQ, 060328 ZSQ) Application for Renewal, Pursuant to Section of the Zoning Resolution of 3 Special Permits and 1 Authorization related to the Silvercup West Project.
Ms. Deller summarized the details of this Application for Board Members. Ms. Deller spoke about parking and the perception of traffic. There was discussion of open space.
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Health and Human Services Committee
Mr. Conley recommended that Board Members to review the Minutes for March provided within the Board Members Monthly Packets.
City Services and Public Safety Committee
Mr. Conley recommended that Board Members to review the Minutes for March provided within the Board Members Monthly Packets.
Environment Committee
Department of Environmental Conservation - Ms. Morehead announced that the NYSDEC has placed the Community Board’s Dutch Kills Basin Project within the top 4 Projects. This Project would receive $2 million dollars of funding however more funding would be needed.
Public Hearing on April 20 th - This Hearing would be hosted at the Newtown Creek Waste Water Treatment plant to discuss the approved Projects. Ms. Morehead spoke about the development of the Greenpoint Boat House and the
Marine Transfer Station - Ms. Morehead spoke about the modifications for trash transportation. Due to Budget Cuts, he Marine Transfer Station was eliminated in
Birth Control for Pigeons - Ms. Morehead explained that
Rain Barrel Give Away Program - The City is offering these barrels without cost. The City would be distributing these barrels in
Transportation Committee
Mr. Conley recommended that Board Members to review the Minutes for March provided within the Board Members Monthly Packets.
E-Waste Program, Broadway Library, 40-20 Steinway,
On Saturday, April 9 th from 10 am to 4 pm the recycling of electronics would be accepted; cell phones, computers, DVD players, VCRs, televisions, etc.
Summer Clothing Swap
Clothing would be “swapped” at the Sunnyside Library. A date for June has not yet been determined. Ms. Morehead would provide that date when it becomes available.
This organization is seeking the support of Community Board 2. Ms. Morehead entertained questions from Board Members.
This Meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted by:
Cheryl Sinnott
The next Community Board 2 Monthly Meeting and Public Hearing has been scheduled for Thursday, May 5 th 2011
April 7, 2011
Community Board 2 Monthly Meeting and Public Hearing
VOTES
Vote on Consumer Affairs Application; Renewable Consent License for an Unenclosed Sidewalk Café with 10 Tables and 20 Seats; Mickey’s Place on 43 rd Street; LTD a/k/a Bar 43
A Motion was made to approve this Renewal Application. The Motion was seconded.
35 In Favor 1 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on FDNY Technical Services Warehouse,
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on FDNY Back-up Radio Transmitter,
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting.
Vote on Sunnyside/Woodside Rezoning, (110207 ZRQ, 110208 ZRQ, 110209 ZRQ)
A Motion was made to approve the Zoning Application. The Motion was seconded.
35 In Favor 1 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on Gotham Center (110225 PPQ); 28-10 Queens Plaza South, Jackson Avenue, 42 nd Road and 28 th Street, Long Island City
A Motion was made to oppose the Application for Tishman Speyer to reduce the amount of parking from 1,150 spaces to 550 spaces. The Motion was seconded.
A Motion was made to oppose the Application for Tishman Speyer to reduce the amount of parking from 1,150 spaces to 550 spaces. The Motion was seconded.
24 In Favor 12 Opposed 2 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote on Silvercup West Renewals (060325 ZSQ, 060326 ZSQ, 060327 ZSQ, 060328 ZSQ) Application for Renewal, Pursuant to Section of the Zoning Resolution of 3 Special Permits and 1 Authorization related to the Silvercup West Project.
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
A Motion was made to approve these Applications. The Motion was seconded.
38 In Favor 0 Opposed 0 Abstentions
Chairperson present but not voting
Vote by Community Board 2 in Opposing of the Renaming of the
A Motion was made that Community Board 2 resolves that the Board is against the renaming of the
The vote was unanimous by a show of hands.
Chairperson present but not voting
Chairperson present but not voting
